Menjawab pertanyaan bersama saat workshop menggunakan Google Docs

Pembaca yang budiman saat workshop Digital citizenship saya menggunakan Google docs sebagai perangkat untuk menjawab pertanyaan bersama dengan seluruh peserta dengan komputernya masing-masing. Hasilnya peserta antusias karena melalui layar didepan tempat pelatihan, mereka bisa langsung melihat siapa menjawab apa. Pada setiap pendapat serta jawaban yang diberikan saya minta mereka mereka menuliskan nama agar mudah dikenali.

google-docs-good-logo

Silahkan nikmati diskusi kami melalui Google docs.

The computer may be an effective trainer, but is it an effective teacher?


Absolutely not. Teacher is different from trainer. Being a teacher is more than just transferring knowledge. To be an effective teacher we need more than knowledge and method. An effective teacher has passion and care which is not provided by computer.(Sugeng)
untuk keefektifan sebagai trainer komputer tidak akan dapat menggantikan manusia yang ahli tentunya. terlebih lagi kalau fungsinya

ditingkatkan menjadi guru. (Supana)

Computer couldn’t become either trainer or teacher. You could train your dog to jump offer the fence but did your dog really learned why they have to jump? Modelling morals, values and ethic are ones that machine couldn’t teach us. (adit)

Computer is only one of tools for us. students need to learn not only knowledge but also value, expression, ethic, etc  (FF)

(fanda)

The computer may be an effective teacher too. Students can gain information and knowledge from the computer. But, the students still need the role of the teacher because the computers are simply machine, they are training the students and providing information. While teacher, they do more than that, teachers need to educate the students both in knowledge and manner.

Media tidak dapat mengantikan peran guru…media dapat memfasilitasi, membantu kinerja guru dalam pembelajaran agar pembelajaran lebih optimal. Sedikit tambahan td saya ngobrol dengan pak agus….beliau berkata “semua orang bisa mengajar”…”asal ada hati”….nah pertanyaannya…apakah komputer/internet punya hati (perasaan)? nah hal itulah yang tidak dapat menggeser posisi guru.

trims (dona).

Tidak dapat dipersamakan sosok guru dengan sebuah benda yakni komputer. Sejatinya guru tidak hanya transfer pengetahuan tapi berperan lebih dari itu sebagai transfer pendidikan, jika komputer mampu mentransfer ilmu yang positif tapi tidak mampu mengubah perilaku buruk menjadi baik, perubahan perilaku dari yang diharapkan masih memerlukan sosok “seorang” yang berdiri di depan kelas.
(komariyah)

I agree.  e-Learning (or learning from the computer)  can be a good tool to complement or supplement the face-to-face classroom-based learning, but the e-tutor can never replace the human teacher. Having been an e-learning facilitator myself, I saw the advantages of e-learning like flexibility in time, place, content per learning session for both facilitator (or mentor) and learner; it takes a lot of creativity and techniques to get the student to stay focused on the online course and pass it. The key to the success of any learning activity remains on the teacher or facilitator.   Teachers matter. (Josie)

Let’s create better tools for teachers, and then help teachers become better users of the tools. (give your opinion?)

(Sugeng)

Definitely agree. Like the proverb says: Bersatu kita teguh, bercerai kita runtuh. Teachers must get together and cooperate to make many useful tootls to make the process of teaching and learning more exciting and efficient. The more people getting together, the more tools we can make, and the more efficient the tools are.🙂

YES! Belajar lagi dan Belajar terus! (adit)

(fanda)

I agree with this sentence. Teachers need tools to support their work as well as becoming the tools for the benefits of the students.
Setuju…masih banyak guru butuh bantuan untuk dapat menggunakan ICT dalam pembelajarannya.
Setelah ini ada tugas baru, mari kita sebarkan apa yang telah kita dapatkan melalui workshop ini kepada guru2 setidaknya disekitar kita. (dona)

Sangat sependapat dengan opini lainya komputer jika disandingkan dengan guru maka mampu mengupgrade ketrampilan guru dalam pembelajaran, sehingga menyenangkan siswa belajar juga menggairahkan guru mengajar.(komariyah)

Yes to that! So, let’s collaborate. (Josie)

Do you believe students learn from computers or teachers?

(Sugeng)

Both. In my case, because I am an English teacher, students still need my guidance for some things that they don’t understand. No matter how “smart” the computer is, sometimes it fails to answer my student’s questions. yet, computer offers a lot of ways to practice English.

Both. They complete each other🙂 (FF)

Potentially both…means teacher and computer have also both the chances to make or not to make students learn (adit)

(fanda)

I believe that students learn from both computers and teachers because information can be found everywhere.

Students learn alot from the teacher. computer assists the teacher as a part of a teaching tool. How can a student learn values of life from a computer? Computer only provides information but a GURU provides life..(Rafael)

Saling melengkapi, dan berkolaborasi. Komputer dan guru..akan menjadi duet maut dalam pembelajaran. (dona)

(Sugeng)

“Saling melengkapi, dan berkolaborasi. Komputer dan guru..akan menjadi duet maut dalam pembelajaran. (dona)”

Wow!!!! Duet maut ya….? Kenapa jadi ingat Inul, ya?🙂 Just kidding. I think it’s a very great way to put it. Sounds so mighty!!!!

Siswa tidak hanya belajar melalui guru, tapi banyak akses yang bisa dilakukan yakni internet/komputer. Keduanya saling complement.

tidak dapat berdiri sendiri. ( komariyah)
Yes I strongly agree. Both teacher and Digital device such as computer could be a best teacher.

Yes,to both. Teaching content and methodology matter. Content and technology encourage creativity and help make learning more fun and interesting for students. (Josie)

One thought on “Menjawab pertanyaan bersama saat workshop menggunakan Google Docs

Tinggalkan Balasan

Isikan data di bawah atau klik salah satu ikon untuk log in:

Logo WordPress.com

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Logout / Ubah )

Gambar Twitter

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Logout / Ubah )

Foto Facebook

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Logout / Ubah )

Foto Google+

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Logout / Ubah )

Connecting to %s